top of page
  • Writer's pictureMAZ

What Is an HMRC Reasonable Excuse in the UK


Understanding HMRC Reasonable Excuse in the UK

The concept of a reasonable excuse under the UK's Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs (HMRC) is crucial for taxpayers. It refers to a situation that prevents an individual or business from meeting their tax obligations despite taking reasonable care to do so. The HMRC acknowledges that unforeseeable or exceptional events, including personal or business disruptions, may constitute a reasonable excuse. Notably, HMRC has accepted COVID-19 as a valid reason for missing tax deadlines, provided the impact is clearly explained and evidenced​​​​​.


What Is an HMRC Reasonable Excuse in the UK

Legal Framework and Criteria

There is no statutory definition for 'reasonable excuse' or 'unreasonable delay' in the UK tax laws. These terms are interpreted based on their ordinary meaning and evaluated on a case-by-case basis, considering each individual's abilities and circumstances. The criteria for a reasonable excuse require that the excuse must have existed on or before the tax obligation's due date. The taxpayer bears the responsibility to convince HMRC that their excuse was valid at the time of the failure​.


Post-Excuse Obligations

Once the circumstances constituting a reasonable excuse end, the taxpayer is expected to rectify their tax compliance issue without unreasonable delay. Failure to do so may result in the excuse being invalidated and the taxpayer becoming liable to penalties. This emphasizes the importance of timely action following the resolution of the circumstances that led to the delay or non-compliance​.


Right to Appeal

If HMRC does not accept a taxpayer’s reasonable excuse, the individual has the right to appeal against the penalty. This appeal process requires careful consideration of the evidence supporting the excuse and may involve a statutory review or tribunal. HMRC’s internal guidelines stress the importance of ensuring that their decision against a reasonable excuse is well-evidenced and considers any special circumstances​.


Understanding what constitutes a reasonable excuse under HMRC's guidelines is crucial for UK taxpayers. The concept is not rigidly defined, allowing for a degree of flexibility and consideration of individual circumstances. The next part of this article will delve deeper into specific examples of reasonable excuses and the forms used for different types of taxes in the UK.

Examples of Reasonable Excuses and Forms for Different Tax Types in the UK


Examples of Reasonable Excuses


  1. COVID-19 Pandemic: HMRC acknowledges the impact of COVID-19 as a reasonable excuse if it prevented meeting tax obligations on time. This excuse must have been applicable on or before the due date of the obligation​.

  2. Bereavement: The death of a partner or close relative impacting the ability to meet tax obligations is usually accepted as a reasonable excuse​.

  3. Postal Delays: Delays due to disruptions in postal services, such as fire, flood, or industrial action at the Post Office, are considered reasonable excuses, especially if supported by a certificate of posting​.

  4. Service Issues with HMRC Online Service: Inability to use HMRC’s online services due to technical issues can be a valid excuse, provided evidence of the error message is given​.

  5. Loss of Tax Records: Loss of records through events like fire, flood, theft, or computer failure is generally accepted as a reasonable excuse, provided the information couldn't be replaced in time​.

  6. Other Circumstances: Unexpected hospital stays, computer or software failures, and delays caused by HMRC are also valid reasons. Members of the Armed Forces on active service overseas are also given consideration​.

  7. Unexpected Stay in Hospital: An unplanned hospitalization that coincides with tax deadlines can be considered a reasonable excuse, particularly if it incapacitates the taxpayer from managing their tax affairs.

  8. Failure of Computer or Software: If a taxpayer’s computer or tax-filing software fails unexpectedly just before or during the process of preparing an online tax return, HMRC may accept this as a reasonable excuse.

  9. Fire, Flood, or Theft: The loss or inaccessibility of crucial tax records or documentation due to disasters like fire or flood, or through theft, can be considered a reasonable excuse, provided the taxpayer could not have anticipated or prevented these events.

  10. Service Issues with HMRC Online Services: Problems with HMRC’s online services, such as system outages or errors during the filing process, can be valid reasons, especially if these issues prevented timely filing or payment.

  11. Delayed Receipt of Online Activation Codes: If a taxpayer registers for HMRC’s online services and does not receive the necessary activation PIN in time to meet a deadline, this could be a reasonable excuse, as long as they file as soon as possible after receiving it.

  12. Delayed Receipt of Replacement ID or Password: Similar to the above, delays in receiving a replacement user ID, password, or activation code for HMRC’s online services can be a valid excuse, particularly if the taxpayer acted promptly to resolve the issue.

  13. Difficulty Obtaining Necessary Information: If a taxpayer experiences unexpected delays or difficulties in obtaining information required for their tax return from third parties, HMRC may consider this a reasonable excuse.

  14. Mental Health Issues: Mental health conditions that significantly impair a person’s ability to manage their tax affairs can be recognized as a reasonable excuse, especially with supporting medical evidence.

  15. Complex Tax Affairs: Taxpayers with particularly complex tax affairs may face unforeseen issues that prevent timely filing or payment. This could be a valid excuse if the complexity is unusual and the taxpayer sought professional advice.

  16. Reliance on a Professional Advisor: If a taxpayer entrusts their tax affairs to a professional advisor who fails to meet deadlines or makes errors, HMRC may consider this a reasonable excuse. However, the taxpayer must demonstrate they took reasonable care in choosing and instructing the advisor.


These examples illustrate the range of scenarios HMRC may consider when evaluating appeals based on reasonable excuses. It's essential for taxpayers to provide detailed explanations and evidence to support their claims when appealing against penalties.

Forms for Different Types of Taxes


Self-Assessment Tax Returns


For agents unable to file online for clients, the designated form should be used along with the paper tax return to avoid penalties. Form SA370 is used for appealing against late filing penalties for Self-Assessment tax returns. This form requires detailed information about the penalty and the taxpayer’s personal details, including the reason for late filing. It must be submitted within 30 days of receiving the late penalty notice from HMRC​​​​​​​​​.


Corporation Tax Returns

For appealing against late filing penalties, the online form provided by HMRC should be completed, printed, and sent to the address on the form. It requires details like the company's Unique Taxpayer Reference (UTR), penalty notice date, penalty amount, and accounting period end date​.


VAT Returns

Form WT2 is used for claiming a reasonable excuse for late submission of online VAT returns. This form is specifically used when a surcharge has been received for late submission​​​.


PAYE (Pay As You Earn) Tax and Reasonable Excuses

For PAYE taxes, which include payroll taxes and National Insurance contributions, the HMRC recognizes several scenarios as reasonable excuses for late payment or filing. These reasons are similar to those applicable for other tax types and include incorrect data on returns, bereavement, natural disasters like fire or flood, ill health, and information technology difficulties. Understanding these excuses is vital for employers to navigate the complexities of PAYE compliance and to mitigate potential penalties for late payments or filings​.


Appealing PAYE Penalties

Employers facing penalties for late PAYE payments have options to appeal. The process involves:

  1. Online Appeals: HMRC’s PAYE for employers service allows online appeals. After logging in, select ‘Appeal a penalty’ and submit your appeal. HMRC provides immediate acknowledgement of submitted appeals, and in some cases, the appeal may be automatically settled by HMRC​.

  2. Written Appeals: Appeals can also be sent in writing to HMRC. It's important to include the ‘Unique ID’ for each penalty from the Notice of Penalty Assessment. This ID is crucial for HMRC to identify the specific penalty being appealed against​.


Navigating HMRC's guidelines for reasonable excuses in PAYE taxes and understanding the appeal process for penalties are critical for employers. These guidelines offer a framework to address tax compliance issues and provide avenues for appeal in cases of reasonable excuses. In the final part of this article, we will explore additional insights and conclude our comprehensive overview of HMRC reasonable excuses and forms for different tax types in the UK.


Reasonable Excuses and Forms for Capital Gains Tax


Capital Gains Tax (CGT) in the UK applies to the profit made when selling, or 'disposing of', an asset that has increased in value. Just like other taxes, individuals faced with a late filing penalty for CGT can appeal to HMRC, providing they have a ‘reasonable excuse’ for missing the 30-day reporting deadline. HMRC includes circumstances like the Covid-19 pandemic as a valid reasonable excuse for CGT late filing appeals​.


Appealing CGT Penalties

The process of appealing CGT penalties involves explaining the reasonable excuse for the late filing. There is no specific form used for this purpose is not readily available. Generally, HMRC provides clear instructions and specific forms for appealing against tax penalties, which can be found on their official website or by contacting HMRC directly for guidance.


Understanding the concept of 'reasonable excuse' in the context of various UK taxes, including PAYE and Capital Gains Tax, is critical for taxpayers to manage their tax obligations effectively. While HMRC provides certain guidelines and examples of what constitutes a reasonable excuse, each case is unique and evaluated on its own merits. Taxpayers should be prepared to provide evidence to support their claims and follow the specific appeal procedures, using the appropriate forms provided by HMRC for each tax type. This comprehensive understanding and approach can aid in successful appeals against penalties and ensure compliance with UK tax regulations.


Understanding the examples of reasonable excuses and knowing the correct forms to use for different types of taxes is essential for UK taxpayers. This knowledge can significantly aid in avoiding penalties and successfully appealing against them. The next part of this article will cover additional information regarding HMRC reasonable excuses and forms for other tax types, ensuring a comprehensive understanding of this important aspect of UK tax compliance.

Can HMRC Waive Tax Penalties?

HMRC (Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs) in the UK holds a significant role in enforcing tax regulations and ensuring compliance. However, there are circumstances under which HMRC may waive or reduce penalties imposed on taxpayers. This article explores the conditions under which HMRC may consider waiving tax penalties, the process involved, and key considerations for taxpayers.


Understanding HMRC Tax Penalties

HMRC imposes penalties for various non-compliance issues, such as late filing of tax returns, late payment of taxes, or errors in tax documents. These penalties are intended to encourage timely and accurate compliance with tax regulations. The penalties can vary depending on the nature and severity of the non-compliance.


Can HMRC Waive Penalties?

Yes, HMRC has the discretion to waive or reduce penalties in certain circumstances. This discretion is exercised under what HMRC terms as 'reasonable excuse'. A reasonable excuse is typically an unexpected or unusual event outside of the taxpayer’s control that prevents them from meeting their tax obligations on time.


Criteria for Waiving Penalties: Reasonable Excuse


A 'reasonable excuse' is not precisely defined in tax law, allowing HMRC some flexibility in its interpretation. Some accepted reasonable excuses include:

  • Serious or life-threatening illness, particularly during the tax payment or filing period.

  • Unforeseen hospital stays or significant health issues.

  • Technical issues with HMRC services, for instance, website downtimes during filing periods.

  • Bereavement, especially if it’s a close relative or partner.

  • Unpredictable postal delays or failures.

  • Impact of natural disasters like floods or fires.

  • The COVID-19 pandemic, which has been specifically acknowledged by HMRC.


Process for Waiving Penalties

To have a penalty waived, a taxpayer must appeal to HMRC, explaining the reasonable excuse and providing any relevant evidence. The appeal can be made online or in writing, depending on the type of tax and penalty. HMRC reviews each case individually and decides based on the specifics of the situation.


Timeliness of the Appeal

The effectiveness of an appeal largely depends on its timeliness. Taxpayers are generally expected to appeal within 30 days of receiving a penalty notice. However, HMRC may consider late appeals if there’s a reasonable excuse for the delay in appealing.


Documenting the Reasonable Excuse

When appealing for a penalty waiver, providing detailed and clear evidence to support the reasonable excuse claim is crucial. This might include medical reports, death certificates, records of disrupted services, or any other relevant documentation.


HMRC’s Discretion and Past Decisions

HMRC exercises discretion when waiving penalties, and past decisions can give insight into how they assess reasonable excuses. However, each case is unique, and decisions are made based on individual circumstances. Taxpayers should not assume a waiver will be granted based on similar cases.


Special Circumstances and Compassionate Grounds

In addition to reasonable excuses, HMRC may consider special circumstances or compassionate grounds. These can include financial hardship, mental health issues, or other personal situations that might impact a taxpayer’s ability to comply with tax obligations.


Importance of Compliance and Future Obligations

While HMRC may waive penalties in some cases, it is crucial for taxpayers to understand the importance of ongoing compliance. A waiver does not exempt taxpayers from future tax obligations, and consistent non-compliance can lead to stricter penalties and less leniency in the future.


Seeking Professional Advice

Tax matters can be complex, and seeking professional advice is often beneficial, especially when dealing with penalties and appeals. Tax professionals can provide guidance on the appeal process, help gather necessary evidence, and represent taxpayers in dealings with HMRC.


HMRC has the capacity to waive tax penalties under specific conditions, primarily when there is a reasonable excuse. The process requires a well-documented appeal and a clear demonstration of how the circumstances affected the taxpayer’s ability to meet their tax obligations. Understanding the criteria and process for penalty waiver is essential for taxpayers facing penalties but should not detract from the importance of regular tax compliance.

Historical Attitude of HMRC in Accepting "Reasonable Excuses" in the UK

Understanding the historical attitude of HMRC (Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs) towards accepting "Reasonable Excuses" in the UK is essential for gaining insights into how taxpayers' appeals have been treated over the years. The approach of HMRC has evolved, influenced by various legal judgments and internal policy revisions.


Initial Stance and Legal Interpretations

Historically, HMRC's interpretation of a 'reasonable excuse' was based on the notion that it should be an unexpected, unusual event that could not be reasonably foreseen or controlled by the taxpayer. This view originated from an early case, C&E Commissioners v Salevon, where the judge described a reasonable excuse as due to "unforeseeable and inescapable misfortune". However, subsequent cases, including C&E Commissioners v Steptoe, began to challenge this narrow interpretation. In Steptoe, the judgment suggested that this definition could not be regarded as a universal test for what constitutes a reasonable excuse​.


Tribunal Criticisms and HMRC’s Response

The rigidity of HMRC's initial stance was increasingly criticized in various tribunal cases. Notably, the First-tier Tribunal (FTT) rejected HMRC’s approach in several cases, such as Barrett v Revenue and Customs and Scott Building Contracts Ltd v Revenue and Customs. These rejections highlighted the need for a more nuanced understanding of what could constitute a reasonable excuse​.


In response to tribunal criticisms, HMRC amended its guidance on reasonable excuses. The updated guidance incorporated a 'reasonable person' test, reflecting a more empathetic and situational approach. This change was based on the judgment in The Clean Car Company case, which asked whether what the taxpayer did (or did not do) was reasonable for a responsible trader, conscious of, and intending to comply with, tax obligations, given their experience and the specific situation they were in​​.


Recent Developments and the Four-Step Approach

More recently, in the Perrin v Revenue and Customs case, the Upper Tribunal (UT) suggested a four-step approach for FTTs when considering a reasonable excuse defense. This approach includes establishing and proving the facts asserted by the taxpayer, objectively deciding if those facts constitute a reasonable excuse, and determining if the taxpayer remedied the failure without unreasonable delay after the excuse ceased. This method offers a structured way for tribunals to assess reasonable excuse claims, ensuring a balanced consideration of each case's specific circumstances​.


Implications for Taxpayers

The evolution in HMRC’s attitude towards reasonable excuses reflects a shift towards a more understanding and contextual evaluation of taxpayers' circumstances. This change is significant for taxpayers as it provides a more equitable framework for appealing penalties. It acknowledges that taxpayers' situations can be complex and varied, necessitating a more flexible and individualized approach to evaluating their appeals.


The historical attitude of HMRC towards accepting "Reasonable Excuses" in the UK has transitioned from a rigid interpretation to a more nuanced and empathetic approach. Legal judgments and tribunal criticisms have played a pivotal role in shaping this evolution, leading to a more balanced and fair treatment of taxpayers' appeals. This shift is crucial for understanding the current landscape of tax appeals and penalties in the UK, offering hope and clarity to taxpayers facing challenges in meeting their tax obligations.


Making an Appeal to HMRC Against a Tax Penalty - A Step by Step Guide

Making an Appeal to HMRC Against a Tax Penalty - A Step by Step Guide

Appealing a tax penalty to HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) in the UK is a structured process. Understanding the steps involved is crucial for anyone seeking to challenge a penalty decision. Here’s a comprehensive guide:

1. Understand Your Penalty 

Before you begin the appeal process, it's essential to understand why HMRC has issued the penalty. Review the penalty notice for details about the penalty type, the reason for its imposition, and the due date for your appeal.

2. File an Appeal within 30 Days 

You usually have 30 days from the date of your penalty notice to file an appeal. In some cases, the notice may specify a different date. It’s important to adhere to this timeframe to ensure your appeal is considered​​​.

3. Choose Your Method of Appeal 

HMRC offers several methods to appeal a penalty:

  • Online Appeals: If you’ve received a fixed late filing penalty (typically £100), you can appeal online, especially if you have a Government Gateway account. This method is straightforward and provides immediate confirmation of your submission​​​.

  • Postal or Phone Appeals: For other penalties or if you cannot appeal online, you can download and complete the postal form SA370, or contact HMRC's Self Assessment general enquiries line. Remember to provide your Unique Taxpayer Reference (UTR) number when contacting HMRC​​​.

4. Explain Your Reasons to HMRC

Clearly state your reasons for appealing the penalty. This is where you can present a "reasonable excuse" if applicable. A reasonable excuse might include unforeseen hospital stays, serious illnesses, technical issues with HMRC services, or other unexpected circumstances. Ensure that your explanation is detailed, with specific dates and events​.

5. Include Relevant Evidence 

Support your appeal with any relevant evidence. This could include medical certificates for health-related excuses, proof of technical issues, or documents showing unforeseen circumstances that led to your non-compliance.

6. Consider Paying the Penalty During Appeal 

While it’s not mandatory, paying the penalty during the appeal process can be beneficial. If your appeal is unsuccessful, this pre-emptive payment can help avoid additional interest charges on the penalty​.

7. Review the Appeal Outcome 

After submitting your appeal, HMRC will review it and inform you of the decision. If your appeal is successful, HMRC will cancel the penalty and refund any payments made, with interest. If your appeal is denied, HMRC will provide reasons and you’ll be required to pay the penalty​.

8. Escalate to a Tribunal if Necessary 

If HMRC denies your appeal and you still believe you have a valid case, you can escalate the matter to a tribunal. This should be done online, and you’ll need to follow the tribunal's instructions for representation and evidence​.

9. Possible Further Escalation 

In certain cases, if the tribunal's decision is not in your favor, you can appeal to the Upper Tribunal. This step is typically reserved for more complex or high-stake cases​.

10. Contact HMRC for Assistance 

If you need further help or clarification at any point during the appeal process, you can contact HMRC's Self Assessment general enquiries for assistance​.


Appealing a tax penalty to HMRC is a process that requires careful attention to detail and adherence to procedures. Whether your appeal involves a simple online submission or a more complex process involving postal forms or tribunals.

How to Write an Appeal Letter to HMRC Expressing a "Reasonable Excuse"

Writing an effective appeal letter to HMRC (Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs) to express a "reasonable excuse" for failing to meet tax obligations is a crucial skill for UK taxpayers. An appeal letter is a formal request to reconsider a decision regarding tax penalties. This guide will walk you through the key elements of crafting such a letter, emphasizing clarity, conciseness, and the inclusion of necessary details.

Understanding 'Reasonable Excuse'

Before drafting your letter, understand what HMRC considers a 'reasonable excuse'. This typically involves unforeseen or uncontrollable events that prevent you from complying with tax obligations, such as serious illness, unforeseen hospital stays, bereavement, technical issues with HMRC services, or significant life disruptions.

1. Start with Your Personal and Tax Details

Begin your letter with your full name, address, contact details, and tax identification number (UTR, Unique Taxpayer Reference). This ensures HMRC can easily identify and reference your case.


2. Clearly State the Purpose of the Letter

In the opening paragraph, explicitly state that the letter is an appeal against a specific penalty, citing the relevant penalty notice number if available.


 3. Explain Your Reasonable Excuse

This section is crucial. Describe the circumstances that led to your non-compliance. Be specific about dates and events, and explain how these events were unforeseeable and beyond your control. This explanation should clearly link the events to your inability to meet your tax obligations.


4. Provide Evidence

Support your explanation with evidence. Attach documents such as medical certificates, hospital admission records, death certificates (in case of bereavement), or communications regarding technical issues with HMRC services.


5. Explain How You Rectified the Situation

Demonstrate that you took action to rectify the situation as soon as you were able. This shows your commitment to compliance and responsibility.


6. Request for Penalty Waiver or Reduction

Conclude by respectfully requesting a waiver or reduction of the penalty, based on your reasonable excuse and efforts to comply thereafter.


7. Provide Your Contact Information for Follow-up

Offer your availability for any further information or discussion required by HMRC.


8. Closing and Signature

End the letter with a formal closing and your signature.


9. Attachments

List the documents you are attaching with the letter.


An appeal letter to HMRC for a 'reasonable excuse' must be clear, detailed, and supported by evidence. It should portray a truthful and compelling narrative of your circumstances while demonstrating your commitment to tax compliance. Remember, the effectiveness of your appeal greatly depends on how well you articulate your case and the evidence you provide.

Sample Appeal Letter to HMRC Expressing a "Reasonable Excuse"

John Doe

123 Apple StreetLondon,


Pone: 07890 123 456

Dated: April 2, 2024

HM Revenue and Customs

Self AssessmentBX9 1AS

United Kingdom

Re: Appeal Against Late Filing PenaltyTax Reference: 1234567890A

Dear Sir/Madam,

I am writing to formally appeal against the late filing penalty imposed on my account, as detailed in the notice dated March 15, 2024, Notice Number: SA456. I believe that circumstances beyond my control constitute a 'reasonable excuse' for this delay.

On February 10, 2024, I was unexpectedly hospitalized due to a severe respiratory infection, as evidenced by the attached medical certificate from London General Hospital. This unforeseen health issue significantly incapacitated me, making it impossible to manage my tax affairs and meet the filing deadline of January 31, 2024.

I have always prioritized compliance with my tax obligations, as my previous filing history will attest. This situation was an anomaly caused by sudden and severe ill health, which I could not have anticipated. I filed my tax return promptly on March 10, 2024, immediately after being discharged and regaining my capacity to handle financial matters.

In light of these exceptional circumstances, I kindly request that the penalty imposed for late filing be reconsidered. I believe that my situation fulfills the criteria for a 'reasonable excuse' as outlined by HMRC. Therefore, I respectfully ask for a waiver or reduction of this penalty.

I am committed to maintaining compliance with my tax obligations and assure you that this delay was an isolated incident caused by unforeseen health issues. I have enclosed all relevant documents to support my appeal, including the hospital admission record and my doctor’s note.

Should you require any further information or clarification, please do not hesitate to contact me at the above number or email address.

Thank you for considering my appeal. I look forward to your understanding and a favorable response.

Yours faithfully,

[Signature]John Doe


  • Medical Certificate from London General Hospital

  • Hospital Admission Record

  • Doctor’s Note

Checking a Reply from HMRC to Your Appeal

When you appeal a tax penalty to HMRC, the time taken for a response can vary depending on the type and complexity of your appeal. As of May 10, 2023, HMRC has an online tool that provides updated information on the expected response times for various types of queries, including appeals. This tool is updated weekly and covers a range of topics like Child Benefit, Corporation Tax, employers’ PAYE, Income Tax, National Insurance, Self Assessment, tax credits, and VAT. It's a valuable resource for both individual taxpayers and agents handling appeals on behalf of clients​.

  1. Expectation of Response Time: The online tool can give you an idea of when to expect a reply from HMRC. This can be particularly useful in managing your expectations and planning any follow-up actions.

  2. Scope of the Tool: The tool includes timeframes for responses on various topics, including appeals. It’s important to regularly check the tool for the most up-to-date information, as response times can change.

  3. Steps to Check the Response Time:

  • Visit the HMRC response time tool.

  • Select the relevant category for your query or appeal, such as Self Assessment or Corporation Tax.

  • Review the information provided for an estimated response time.

  1. If Your Query Falls Outside the Tool's Scope: If your appeal or query doesn’t fall under the categories listed in the tool, or if you need further assistance, you should contact HMRC directly. This can be done online, by phone, or in writing.

  2. Keeping Track of Your Appeal: It's important to keep a record of your appeal submission, including any reference numbers or confirmation emails. This will be useful if you need to follow up with HMRC or reference your appeal in future communications.

  3. Contacting HMRC for Updates: If the response time has passed and you haven't heard back, you can contact HMRC for an update. Be sure to have your appeal reference number and personal details handy to facilitate the process.

  4. Understanding HMRC’s Workload: HMRC handles a large volume of queries and appeals, which can affect response times. The updated weekly information on the tool takes into account their current workload and processing times.

  5. Planning for Delays: Given the varying nature of response times, it's wise to plan for potential delays, especially if your appeal is complex or requires additional review.


Regularly checking HMRC's online tool for expected response times can provide clarity on when to expect a reply to your appeal. If your situation requires immediate attention or falls outside the scope of the tool, direct contact with HMRC is advisable. Remember, staying informed and proactive in your communications with HMRC can help manage the appeal process more effectively.

The Marlow Rowing Club Case - A Lesson From the History

In the case of Marlow Rowing Club v R & C Commrs [2020] BVC 525, the Upper Tribunal (UT) played a pivotal role in addressing the complexities of tax law, particularly in the context of reasonable excuses for incorrect tax practices. This case highlights the nuanced and intricate nature of tax regulations and the importance of professional advice in navigating them.

Marlow Rowing Club, after seeking professional advice, issued a certificate to obtain zero-rating on construction services for a new clubhouse, believing it would be used partly for a relevant charitable purpose. This decision was influenced by a similar case, Longridge on the Thames, which initially saw favorable rulings from the First-tier Tribunal (FTT) and UT, but was later overturned by the Court of Appeal.

When HMRC assessed a penalty against Marlow for incorrectly issuing the certificate, the club appealed to the FTT, arguing a reasonable excuse based on professional advice and existing legal precedents. The FTT, however, found that Marlow should have sought a clear decision from HMRC due to the uncertainties in their situation. The UT later overturned this decision, emphasizing that HMRC wouldn’t have provided an appealable decision prior to the certificate's issuance.

The UT's decision to find in favor of Marlow rested on the principle of what was objectively reasonable for the club under their specific circumstances. Despite having tax and professional expertise within their committee, the UT recognized that relying on specialist VAT advice, in light of the then-recent FTT decision in Longridge, was reasonable. This case underscores the importance of context and individual circumstances in determining what constitutes a reasonable excuse.

Furthermore, the Marlow Rowing Club case serves as a reminder of the dynamic nature of tax law interpretations and the value of professional advice in such complex scenarios. It also illustrates the challenges organizations face when navigating ambiguous tax laws and the importance of maintaining credible documentation and advice from professionals.

The Marlow Rowing Club case teaches a crucial lesson about "Reasonable Excuse" in tax law: Context and professional advice are key. Even with in-house expertise, relying on specialized advice in complex scenarios is prudent. This case illustrates the fluidity of tax law interpretation and underscores the necessity of staying informed about legal precedents. It highlights that what's reasonable for one entity, given its unique circumstances, may differ for another. For organizations navigating tax regulations, it's a reminder to seek expert advice and maintain thorough documentation to support their decisions, particularly in ambiguous legal landscapes.

Why You Must Use the Services of a Professional Accountant to Present Your "Reasonable Excuse" to HMRC

Why You Must Use the Services of a Professional Accountant to Present Your "Reasonable Excuse" to HMRC

Dealing with HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) regarding tax matters, especially when presenting a "reasonable excuse" for non-compliance, can be a complex and daunting task for most individuals. This is where the expertise of a professional accountant becomes invaluable. In this article, we'll explore the reasons why enlisting the services of a professional accountant is critical when presenting a "reasonable excuse" to HMRC.


1. Expertise in Tax Laws and HMRC Procedures

Professional accountants possess comprehensive knowledge of UK tax laws and are well-versed in HMRC procedures and policies. They understand the nuances of tax regulations and can interpret how they apply to specific circumstances. This expertise is crucial in formulating a "reasonable excuse" that aligns with HMRC’s guidelines and expectations.


2. Identifying and Articulating a Valid "Reasonable Excuse"

One of the key roles of an accountant in this context is to identify whether a client’s situation qualifies as a "reasonable excuse" under HMRC's criteria. They can effectively articulate the circumstances in a manner that is coherent and persuasive to HMRC, increasing the likelihood of a successful appeal.


3. Professional Representation

Dealing with HMRC can be intimidating for individuals. Accountants act as professional representatives, bridging the gap between the taxpayer and HMRC. Their experience in dealing with tax authorities means they can navigate the system more efficiently and effectively, reducing the stress and burden on the taxpayer.


4. Gathering and Presenting Supporting Evidence

A successful "reasonable excuse" claim often hinges on the quality of supporting evidence. Accountants can help gather, organize, and present relevant evidence to substantiate the claim. They understand what types of evidence are most compelling to HMRC and how to present them in a structured and clear manner.


5. Ensuring Compliance and Avoiding Future Issues

Accountants not only assist in resolving current issues with HMRC but also provide advice to ensure ongoing compliance. They can help implement systems and practices to prevent future instances of non-compliance, thereby avoiding similar situations down the line.


6. Handling Complex Cases

Some "reasonable excuse" cases can be particularly complex, involving intricate tax situations or substantial amounts of money. Accountants are equipped to handle these complexities, ensuring that all aspects of the case are thoroughly considered and addressed.


7. Timely and Accurate Filing

Professional accountants ensure that all necessary documents and appeals are filed timely and accurately with HMRC. Timeliness is a critical factor in the acceptance of a "reasonable excuse," and accountants can help avoid delays that might jeopardize the appeal.


8. Mitigating Financial Risks

Inaccurate or unsuccessful "reasonable excuse" claims can result in significant financial penalties. An accountant’s involvement reduces the risk of costly errors and can lead to a more favorable outcome, potentially saving substantial sums in penalties.


9. Providing Peace of Mind

Knowing that a qualified professional is handling their case gives taxpayers peace of mind. It allows them to focus on their business or personal affairs, confident that their tax issues are being managed effectively.


10. Negotiation Skills

Professional accountants often possess strong negotiation skills. If there's room for negotiation with HMRC regarding the penalties or the terms of compliance, an accountant can be an invaluable asset in these discussions.


11. Objectivity and Professional Judgment

Accountants provide an objective viewpoint, essential for making sound decisions. Their professional judgment can be crucial in determining the best course of action and in presenting the case in a balanced and reasonable manner.


12. Experience with Similar Cases

Experienced accountants likely have dealt with similar cases in the past. This experience is beneficial as they can draw on previous successful appeals to inform the current strategy.


13. Maintaining Professional Relationships

Accountants often have established professional relationships with HMRC, which can be advantageous in negotiations and communications. These relationships, built on mutual respect and understanding, can facilitate smoother interactions and potentially more favorable outcomes.


14. Addressing Complications

If complications arise during the appeal process, accountants have the skills and resources to address them effectively. This might include responding to additional inquiries from HMRC or adjusting the strategy based on new information.


15. Saving Time and Resources

Navigating tax laws and HMRC procedures can be time-consuming and resource-intensive. By hiring an accountant, individuals and businesses can save time and resources that can be better utilized elsewhere.


The role of a professional accountant in presenting a "reasonable excuse" to HMRC is multifaceted and crucial. Their expertise in tax law, experience with HMRC procedures, ability to gather and present evidence, and their professional judgment and negotiation skills make them an invaluable ally in these situations. While there is a cost involved in hiring an accountant, the potential benefits, including reduced stress, decreased financial risk, and increased likelihood of a successful outcome, far outweigh the expense. In navigating the complexities of tax compliance and disputes with HMRC, the assistance of a professional accountant is not just a luxury but a necessity.


Most Important 20 FAQs about "HMRC Reasonable Excuse in the UK"


Q1: What constitutes a 'reasonable excuse' for VAT return delays? 

A: A reasonable excuse for VAT return delays can include unexpected business disruptions, serious illness, or technical issues with HMRC's online services.

Q2: Can a lack of funds be considered a reasonable excuse for late tax payments? 

A: Generally, a lack of funds is not considered a reasonable excuse unless it's due to circumstances beyond your control.

Q3: Is forgetting to file or pay a valid reasonable excuse? 

A: Forgetting to file or pay is usually not accepted as a reasonable excuse by HMRC.

Q4: How long do I have to appeal a penalty using a reasonable excuse? 

A: You should appeal as soon as possible, typically within 30 days from the date of the penalty notice.

Q5: Can technical issues with personal tax software be a reasonable excuse? 

A: Yes, if you can demonstrate that unexpected technical issues with your tax software directly prevented you from filing on time.

Q6: Does HMRC accept mental health issues as a reasonable excuse? 

A: Yes, mental health issues can be considered, especially if they significantly impact your ability to manage tax affairs.

Q7: Can a reasonable excuse be applied to late payment of Corporation Tax? 

A: Yes, if you can provide evidence that an unforeseeable event affected your ability to pay Corporation Tax on time.

Q8: Are there any specific forms to use when claiming a reasonable excuse for late PAYE payments? 

A: You can use HMRC’s PAYE for employers service online to appeal penalties related to PAYE.

Q9: How does HMRC verify the validity of a reasonable excuse? 

A: HMRC will review the evidence and circumstances provided in your appeal to verify the validity of your reasonable excuse.

Q10: Can I claim a reasonable excuse for late filing due to a family emergency? 

A: Yes, a family emergency, particularly if it's critical and unforeseen, can be considered a reasonable excuse.

Q11: What evidence is required to support a claim of illness as a reasonable excuse? 

A: Medical certificates, doctor’s notes, or hospital admission records can be used as evidence for illness.

Q12: Are accountants liable if HMRC rejects a reasonable excuse they suggested? 

A: Accountants are not typically liable for the rejection of a reasonable excuse by HMRC, but they are responsible for providing accurate advice based on their professional judgment.

Q13: Is a reasonable excuse applicable to inheritance tax liabilities? 

A: Yes, it can be applied to inheritance tax, provided you can demonstrate that an unforeseeable event prevented timely compliance.

Q14: How does HMRC treat reasonable excuse claims for taxpayers residing overseas? 

A: Taxpayers residing overseas are still eligible to claim reasonable excuses, but they must demonstrate how their location impacted their ability to comply.

Q15: Can business disruptions due to market conditions be a reasonable excuse? 

A: If you can prove that sudden and unforeseeable market conditions directly impacted your ability to comply, it may be considered.

Q16: Are reasonable excuses considered for late filing of Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) returns? 

A: Yes, reasonable excuses can be applied to SDLT returns if unexpected circumstances prevented timely filing.

Q17: How does HMRC handle reasonable excuse claims for tax credits? 

A: HMRC assesses these claims on a case-by-case basis, considering the specific circumstances and evidence provided.

Q18: Can postal delays be a valid reason for a reasonable excuse claim? 

A: Yes, particularly if you can provide evidence of postal delays, such as a certificate of posting.

Q19: Is a technical failure on the HMRC website a valid reasonable excuse? 

A: Yes, if you can demonstrate that HMRC's website failure directly prevented you from meeting your tax obligations.

Q20: Can I amend a reasonable excuse claim after submission? 

A: It's best to provide all relevant information initially, but if necessary, you can contact HMRC to amend or provide additional information for your claim.

Top of Form.

59 views0 comments


bottom of page