Tax Implications of Selling a House Below Market Value
- MAZ
- May 2
- 16 min read
Index:
The Audio Summary of the Key Points of the Article:
Listen to our podcast for a comprehensive discussion on:
Tax Implications of Selling a House Below Market Value
Understanding Capital Gains Tax When Selling Below Market Value
Selling a house below its market value in the UK can trigger complex tax implications, primarily through Capital Gains Tax (CGT) and potentially Inheritance Tax (IHT). The key issue is that HMRC deems the seller to have received the property’s market value for CGT purposes, even if the actual sale price is lower, especially when selling to a connected person like a family member. This article dives deep into the tax rules, offering practical guidance for UK taxpayers and business owners, backed by the latest 2025/26 tax year data from GOV.UK and HMRC.
Capital Gains Tax Basics and Market Value Rule
What Is CGT and When Does It Apply?
CGT is a tax on the profit (or gain) made when you sell or dispose of an asset, such as a property, that has increased in value. For residential properties—like a second home or buy-to-let—you pay CGT on the gain above your annual tax-free allowance, known as the Annual Exempt Amount (AEA), which is £3,000 for individuals in the 2025/26 tax year. Couples jointly owning a property can combine this, allowing up to £6,000 tax-free.
When you sell a house below market value, HMRC’s market value rule kicks in, particularly for transactions with connected persons (e.g., spouse, siblings, parents, children, or business partners). Per HMRC, the seller is treated as having received the property’s open market value at the time of sale, not the actual sale price. This ensures you can’t dodge CGT by selling cheaply to a relative. For example, if you sell a house worth £300,000 to your child for £100,000, HMRC calculates CGT based on a £300,000 sale price, minus your purchase costs and AEA.
CGT Rates and Tax Bands for 2025/26
CGT rates depend on your income tax band and the type of asset. For residential properties in 2025/26, the rates are:
Basic rate taxpayers (income up to £50,270): 18% on gains within the basic rate band.
Higher and additional rate taxpayers (income above £50,270): 24% on gains.
Your taxable income, after deductions like the Personal Allowance (£12,570 for 2025/26), determines your band. If your income plus gains pushes you into a higher band, you’ll pay 24% on the portion above £50,270. Here’s a quick table from HMRC data:
Tax Band | Income Range (2025/26) | CGT Rate on Residential Property |
Basic Rate | £12,571–£50,270 | 18% |
Higher/Additional Rate | Above £50,270 | 24% |
Source: GOV.UK - Capital Gains Tax Rates
Case Study: Elspeth’s Below-Market Sale
Let’s look at Elspeth, a basic rate taxpayer in Manchester, who bought a buy-to-let flat in 2015 for £150,000. In September 2025, she sells it to her son for £200,000, though its market value is £300,000. Elspeth’s taxable income is £30,000, leaving £20,270 of her basic rate band (£50,270 - £30,000).
Gain Calculation: HMRC uses the market value (£300,000) minus purchase price (£150,000) = £150,000 gain.
AEA Deduction: Subtract the £3,000 AEA = £147,000 taxable gain.
Taxable Portions:
First £20,270 (within basic rate band) taxed at 18% = £3,648.60.
Remaining £126,730 taxed at 24% = £30,415.20.
Total CGT: £3,648.60 + £30,415.20 = £34,063.80.
Elspeth must report this via a residential property return within 60 days of completion and pay the tax, per HMRC rules. If she’d sold at market value to a stranger, the CGT would be the same, showing the market value rule’s impact.
Allowable Deductions and Reliefs
Deductible Costs to Reduce Your Gain
You can reduce your taxable gain by deducting costs like:
Purchase costs: Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT), legal fees, surveyor fees.
Sale costs: Estate agent fees, solicitor fees.
Improvement costs: Major renovations (e.g., a loft conversion), but not routine maintenance.
For Elspeth, if she spent £5,000 on legal fees and £10,000 on a kitchen upgrade, her gain drops to £135,000 (£150,000 - £15,000). After the AEA, her taxable gain is £132,000, lowering her CGT bill.
Private Residence Relief (PRR)
If the property was your main home for its entire ownership, Private Residence Relief exempts you from CGT. If you lived there part-time, you get partial relief, calculated pro-rata. For example, if Elspeth lived in the flat for 5 of its 10 years, 50% of the gain is exempt. However, selling below market value to a connected person doesn’t affect PRR eligibility, as the gain is still based on market value.
Allowable Deductions Vs. Reliefs
Reporting and Payment Deadlines
The 60-Day Rule
For UK residential property sales triggering CGT, you must:
Submit a residential property return to HMRC within 60 days of completion.
Pay the estimated CGT within the same period.
Failure to meet this deadline incurs penalties and interest. Use HMRC’s online Capital Gains Tax on UK property account to report and pay. The final CGT is adjusted in your Self-Assessment tax return, due by 31 January following the tax year (e.g., 31 January 2027 for 2025/26).
Emergency Tax Concerns
If you’re a business owner with payroll, selling a property doesn’t directly impact your PAYE or payroll taxes. However, if the gain pushes you into a higher tax band, it could affect your overall tax code, potentially causing emergency tax on other income. Hey, don’t sweat it! Check your tax code via GOV.UK’s Personal Tax Account to avoid overpaying.
This part sets the foundation, focusing on CGT mechanics and the market value rule. The next sections will explore Inheritance Tax implications and strategic tax planning to minimise liabilities when selling below market value.
Inheritance Tax and Gifting Considerations When Selling Below Market Value
Selling a house below market value in the UK doesn’t just affect Capital Gains Tax (CGT); it can also trigger Inheritance Tax (IHT) implications, especially when the transaction is seen as a gift or partial gift. This part dives into how IHT applies, the rules around gifting property, and practical steps to navigate these tax obligations. We’ll use 2025/26 tax year data from HMRC and GOV.UK, verified for accuracy, to provide actionable insights for UK taxpayers and business owners.
Inheritance Tax and the Gift Rule
When Does IHT Apply to Below-Market Sales?
When you sell a property below its market value, HMRC may treat the difference between the sale price and the market value as a gift for IHT purposes. This is particularly relevant if you sell to a connected person like a family member. IHT is a tax on the transfer of assets, typically applied when you die, but certain lifetime transfers, known as Potentially Exempt Transfers (PETs) or Chargeable Lifetime Transfers (CLTs), can trigger IHT rules.
For example, if you sell a house worth £500,000 to your daughter for £200,000, the £300,000 difference is considered a gift. This gift could reduce your IHT nil-rate band (£325,000 for 2025/26, or £500,000 if the residence nil-rate band applies) if you die within seven years. If the gift exceeds the nil-rate band, IHT at 40% may apply, with taper relief reducing the tax if you survive three to seven years.
Here’s a table outlining IHT taper relief, sourced from GOV.UK - Inheritance Tax:
Years Between Gift and Death | Taper Relief (% Reduction) | Effective IHT Rate |
0–3 | 0% | 40% |
3–4 | 20% | 32% |
4–5 | 40% | 24%hopefully, Inheritance Tax (IHT) rules can be complex, but let’s break it down. If you sell a house below market value, the difference between the sale price and the market value might be treated as a gift for IHT purposes, especially if you’re selling to a family member. This could affect your nil-rate band—the amount you can pass on tax-free when you die (£325,000 for 2025/26, or up to £500,000 if you’re passing your main home to direct descendants). If you die within seven years of the gift, it could be taxed at 40%, though taper relief might reduce this if you survive longer than three years. |
Here’s a quick table to show how taper relief works, straight from GOV.UK - Inheritance Tax:
Years Between Gift and Death | Taper Relief (% Reduction) | Effective IHT Rate |
0–3 | 0% | 40% |
3–4 | 20% | 32% |
4–5 | 40% | 24% |
5–6 | 60% | 16% |
6–7 | 80% | 8% |
7+ | 100% | 0% |
Potentially Exempt Transfers (PETs) Explained
A below-market sale to a connected person is often classified as a PET. If you survive seven years after the gift, it’s exempt from IHT. If you die sooner, the gift is added back to your estate for IHT calculations. For business owners, this is critical: if you’re gifting a property to reduce your estate’s value (a common tax-planning move), you need to understand the seven-year clock.
Case Study: Mortimer’s Family Gift
Mortimer, a retired business owner in Bristol, owns a second home worth £600,000. In March 2025, he sells it to his niece for £250,000, creating a £350,000 gift. His taxable estate is £800,000, including other assets. If Mortimer dies in 2028 (three years later), here’s how IHT works:
Gift Value: £350,000 (market value £600,000 - sale price £250,000).
Nil-Rate Band: £325,000 (no residence nil-rate band, as it’s not his main home).
Taxable Gift: £350,000 - £325,000 = £25,000.
IHT Due: £25,000 × 40% = £10,000. With 20% taper relief (3–4 years), it’s £8,000.
Mortimer’s estate must pay £8,000 IHT on the gift, plus IHT on the rest of his estate. If he’d survived seven years, the gift would’ve been IHT-free. This shows why timing matters.
Gifting Exemptions and Reliefs
Annual Gift Exemption
You can gift up to £3,000 per tax year without IHT implications, but this applies to all gifts, not just property. If Mortimer hadn’t used his 2025/26 exemption, £3,000 of the £350,000 gift would be exempt, reducing the taxable gift to £347,000. You can also carry forward one year’s unused exemption, so if Mortimer didn’t gift anything in 2024/25, he could exempt £6,000.
Small Gifts and Regular Payments
You can make unlimited small gifts of £250 per person per year, but these can’t apply to the same person as the £3,000 exemption. Regular payments out of income (e.g., helping your child with mortgage payments) are also IHT-free if they don’t affect your standard of living. These exemptions are less relevant for large property gifts but can complement your tax strategy.
IHT: Gifting Exemptions and Reliefs
Anti-Avoidance Rules and HMRC Scrutiny
Gifts with Reservation of Benefit
If you gift a property but continue to benefit from it (e.g., living in it rent-free), HMRC treats it as a gift with reservation of benefit. The property remains in your estate for IHT purposes, nullifying the tax-saving intent. For example, if Mortimer sells his second home to his niece but continues using it for holidays, it’s still part of his estate at death, valued at its market value then, not the £350,000 gift amount.
HMRC Investigations
HMRC closely scrutinizes below-market sales, especially to connected persons, to prevent tax avoidance. They may request a professional valuation to confirm the market value, so keep records like estate agent appraisals or RICS valuations. If HMRC suspects deliberate undervaluation, you could face penalties up to 100% of the tax due, plus interest. Always get a market valuation at the sale date to avoid disputes.
Practical Steps to Manage IHT
Document Everything
Keep detailed records of the sale, including:
Independent property valuation (e.g., from a RICS surveyor).
Sale agreement and conveyancing documents.
Receipts for allowable costs (e.g., legal fees).
These help if HMRC queries the transaction years later, especially if you die within seven years.
Consider Trusts
For business owners, placing the property in a discretionary trust before selling can offer IHT benefits, but it’s complex. The gift to the trust is a Chargeable Lifetime Transfer (CLT), taxed at 20% above the nil-rate band. Trusts avoid the seven-year PET rule but require careful planning with a tax adviser, as they’re costly to set up and maintain.
This section has unpacked IHT and gifting rules, showing how they intertwine with below-market sales. The final part will explore tax planning strategies and real-life scenarios to minimise your tax burden while staying HMRC-compliant.
Strategic Tax Planning and Real-Life Scenarios for Below-Market Sales
Selling a house below market value in the UK requires careful tax planning to minimise Capital Gains Tax (CGT) and Inheritance Tax (IHT) liabilities while staying compliant with HMRC rules. This final part explores advanced strategies, real-life scenarios, and practical tips tailored for UK taxpayers and business owners. Using verified 2025/26 tax year data from GOV.UK and HMRC, we’ll address common concerns like overtaxing and provide actionable steps to optimise your tax position.
Advanced Tax Planning Strategies
Timing the Sale to Optimise CGT
Timing your property sale can significantly reduce CGT. If your taxable income is close to the £50,270 higher-rate threshold for 2025/26, consider spreading gains across multiple tax years. For example, you could sell part of the property (e.g., a share) in one tax year and the rest in the next, using two £3,000 Annual Exempt Amounts (AEA). This is particularly useful for business owners with fluctuating incomes, as it keeps gains within the 18% CGT rate band.
Using Spousal Transfers
If you’re married or in a civil partnership, transferring the property (or a share) to your spouse before selling can double your tax-free allowances. Spousal transfers are CGT- and IHT-free, and each spouse gets a £3,000 AEA. For example, if you own a property with a £100,000 gain, transferring half to your spouse means each reports a £50,000 gain, potentially using both AEAs (£6,000 total) and staying in the basic rate band for lower CGT.
Case Study: Bronwen and Idris’ Joint Strategy
Bronwen and Idris, a married couple in Cardiff, own a buy-to-let property bought in 2010 for £200,000, now valued at £400,000. In July 2025, they sell it to their son for £250,000. The market value rule means HMRC assesses CGT on the £400,000 market value. Here’s how they optimise their tax:
Step 1: Spousal Transfer: Bronwen, who owns the property, transfers half to Idris. No CGT applies.
Step 2: Calculate Gains: Each has a £100,000 gain (£200,000 market value - £100,000 purchase cost per half).
Step 3: Apply AEAs: Each deducts £3,000 AEA, leaving £97,000 taxable gain per person.
Step 4: CGT Rates: Both are basic rate taxpayers (income £35,000 each). Their remaining basic rate band (£50,270 - £35,000 = £15,270) is taxed at 18% (£2,748.60 each). The remaining £81,730 per person is taxed at 24% (£19,615.20 each).
Total CGT: £2,748.60 + £19,615.20 = £22,363.80 per person, or £44,727.60 total.
Without the spousal transfer, Bronwen would’ve paid CGT on the full £200,000 gain, likely pushing her into the 24% rate for most of it, increasing the tax bill. They report the sale via HMRC’s online system within 60 days and adjust in their 2025/26 Self-Assessment.
Mitigating IHT Through Strategic Gifting
Outright Gifts vs. Trusts
To reduce IHT, you might consider gifting the property outright rather than selling below market value. An outright gift is a Potentially Exempt Transfer (PET), IHT-free if you survive seven years. However, if you need some control over the property (e.g., ensuring it benefits multiple heirs), a discretionary trust might work. Trusts are complex—gifts to trusts are Chargeable Lifetime Transfers (CLTs), taxed at 20% above the £325,000 nil-rate band—but they avoid the seven-year PET rule. For example, gifting a £500,000 property to a trust incurs £35,000 IHT (£500,000 - £325,000 × 20%), but the property is immediately outside your estate.
Regular Gifts Out of Income
Business owners with surplus income can gift regular payments (e.g., to help a child with mortgage payments) without IHT implications, provided they don’t affect your standard of living. Document these payments meticulously, as HMRC may review them if your estate is audited. This strategy complements below-market sales by reducing your estate’s value over time.
Mitigating IHT Through Strategic Gifting
Handling HMRC Compliance and Disputes
Avoiding Overtaxing and Securing Refunds
If HMRC overestimates your CGT due to an incorrect market valuation, you can challenge it with evidence like a RICS surveyor’s report. For example, if HMRC values your property at £400,000 but a surveyor confirms £350,000, your taxable gain drops, reducing CGT. File an amended residential property return within 12 months of the original deadline to claim a refund. Check your tax code via GOV.UK’s Personal Tax Account to ensure the gain doesn’t trigger an emergency tax on other income, especially if you’re a PAYE employee or business owner with payroll.
Record-Keeping for HMRC Audits
HMRC can investigate below-market sales up to seven years after your death for IHT or six years after a CGT return for errors. Keep:
Professional valuations at the sale date.
Sale contracts and conveyancing documents.
Receipts for deductible costs (e.g., improvements, legal fees).
Digital records are ideal, as HMRC accepts electronic submissions. If audited, respond promptly to avoid penalties, which can reach 100% of unpaid tax for deliberate errors.
Real-Life Scenario: Navigating a Dispute
In 2024, Sioned, a London business owner, sold a rental property worth £700,000 to her brother for £400,000. HMRC assessed CGT on a £700,000 market value, calculating a £450,000 gain (after £250,000 purchase costs). Sioned’s surveyor valued the property at £650,000 due to structural issues. She submitted the valuation, reducing her gain to £400,000. After her £3,000 AEA, her taxable gain was £397,000. As a higher-rate taxpayer, she paid £95,280 CGT (£397,000 × 24%). Without the challenge, she’d have overpaid by £12,000. Sioned also documented the sale for IHT, as the £250,000 gift could be taxed if she dies before 2031.
Addressing Common Taxpayer Concerns
Impact on Payroll and Tax Codes
For business owners, a below-market sale doesn’t directly affect PAYE or payroll taxes, but a large CGT bill could push you into a higher income tax band, altering your tax code. This might cause temporary overtaxing on your salary or dividends. Use HMRC’s online tools to update your tax code quickly, avoiding emergency tax issues.
Planning for Refunds
If you overpay CGT (e.g., due to an incorrect valuation or missed deductions), claim a refund via your Self-Assessment return by 31 January following the tax year. For 2025/26 sales, this is 31 January 2027. Keep evidence of allowable costs, as HMRC may request it during refund processing.
This section wraps up our guide with strategies to minimise tax, handle disputes, and address practical concerns. By combining CGT and IHT planning with robust record-keeping, you can sell below market value confidently, saving thousands while staying HMRC-compliant.
Summary of All the Most Important Points Mentioned In the Above Article
Selling a house below market value in the UK triggers Capital Gains Tax (CGT) based on the property’s market value, not the sale price, when sold to a connected person.
The CGT rates for residential properties in 2025/26 are 18% for basic rate taxpayers and 24% for higher/additional rate taxpayers, with a £3,000 Annual Exempt Amount (AEA).
Allowable deductions, like purchase costs, sale costs, and improvements, can reduce your taxable gain, while Private Residence Relief may exempt main homes.
A residential property return must be filed, and CGT paid, within 60 days of sale completion, with penalties for late submissions.
The difference between the sale price and market value is treated as a gift for Inheritance Tax (IHT) purposes, potentially taxable if you die within seven years.
IHT taper relief reduces the tax on gifts from 40% to 0% if you survive three to seven years, with a £325,000 nil-rate band for 2025/26.
Gifts with reservation of benefit, like living in the gifted property, keep it in your estate for IHT, negating tax savings.
Spousal transfers before a sale can double the AEA and keep gains in the lower CGT rate band, saving significant tax.
Robust record-keeping, including professional valuations and sale documents, is crucial to avoid HMRC penalties or disputes over valuations.
Strategic gifting, trusts, or regular payments out of income can reduce IHT, but require careful planning to comply with HMRC anti-avoidance rules.
FAQs
Click on the arrow above to expand the text
Disclaimer:
The information provided in our articles is for general informational purposes only and is not intended as professional advice. While we strive to keep the information up-to-date and correct, My Tax Accountant makes no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, about the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability with respect to the website or the information, products, services, or related graphics contained in the articles for any purpose. Any reliance you place on such information is therefore strictly at your own risk. The graphs may also not be 100% reliable.
We encourage all readers to consult with a qualified professional before making any decisions based on the information provided. The tax and accounting rules in the UK are subject to change and can vary depending on individual circumstances. Therefore, My Tax Accountant cannot be held liable for any errors, omissions, or inaccuracies published. The firm is not responsible for any losses, injuries, or damages arising from the display or use of this information.
Comments