top of page
Writer's pictureMAZ

What is PILON and Is PILON Pensionable by HMRC?

Index


What is PILON and Is PILON Pensionable by HMRC


Understanding PILON and Its Pensionable Status


What is PILON?

Payment in Lieu of Notice (PILON) is a term that frequently appears in employment contracts and separation agreements. Essentially, PILON is a payment made to an employee to cover the notice period when an employer wishes to terminate employment immediately. Instead of having the employee work through the notice period, the employer compensates them for it, allowing an immediate departure. This payment often includes the employee's basic salary that they would have earned during the notice period. However, it can also encompass additional contractual benefits, depending on the specific employment terms.


Why is PILON Important?

PILON is significant in the employment landscape because it provides financial continuity to the employee while allowing the employer flexibility in workforce management. But it comes with specific tax and pension implications, which can impact both parties. For employees, understanding whether PILON is subject to tax, NICs, or pension contributions is essential for accurate financial planning. For employers, correctly categorizing PILON payments ensures compliance with HMRC regulations and minimizes the risk of penalties.


Is PILON Pensionable?

A primary question often asked by employees and employers alike is whether PILON is pensionable. Typically, the answer is no—PILON is not automatically considered pensionable by HMRC in the UK. This means that, in most cases, payments made under PILON do not contribute toward an employee’s pension fund. However, the specific treatment of PILON depends on several factors, primarily the terms outlined in the employment contract and the nature of the pension scheme in place.


Factors Affecting the Pensionable Status of PILON

  1. Employment Contract: Whether PILON includes pension contributions depends largely on the employment contract. Some contracts explicitly include pension contributions as part of PILON, while others do not. In cases where the contract clearly states that pension contributions are included within the PILON payment, HMRC may consider it pensionable. However, this is relatively rare, as most employers choose not to make PILON payments pensionable to simplify payroll processing and tax treatment.

  2. Nature of the Pension Scheme: The type of pension scheme can also influence whether PILON is pensionable. For example, in defined contribution schemes, where contributions are based on a percentage of earnings, PILON is usually non-pensionable unless specified otherwise. In contrast, defined benefit schemes may treat PILON differently, particularly if the contract specifies that contributions continue during the notice period.

  3. Discretion of Employers: Some employers choose to make PILON pensionable as part of broader benefits packages, especially in senior roles or industries where continuity of benefits is a standard practice. However, this remains at the employer’s discretion and is not mandated by HMRC regulations.


Tax and NIC Implications of PILON

One critical aspect of PILON is its tax and NIC treatment. According to HMRC guidelines, PILON payments are typically subject to income tax and National Insurance Contributions. This stems from the fact that PILON represents a replacement for the income an employee would have earned during their notice period.


  1. Income Tax: From the perspective of income tax, PILON is treated as taxable earnings. This means that it is subject to income tax at the employee's normal rate. For example, if an employee is in the 20% tax bracket, their PILON will be taxed at this rate, potentially affecting their overall earnings from the termination payment.

  2. National Insurance Contributions (NICs): Similar to income tax, NICs are typically applied to PILON. Both employer and employee NICs apply, mirroring the treatment of regular earnings. Employers should calculate NICs accordingly, ensuring compliance with HMRC rules. It’s worth noting that since PILON is taxable, it can reduce the tax-free amount that employees might otherwise receive under the £30,000 termination payment exemption.

  3. Thresholds and Exemptions: Notably, termination payments that do not exceed £30,000 may be exempt from tax, provided they meet specific criteria. However, this threshold rarely applies to PILON, as HMRC views PILON as a form of earnings rather than a tax-free termination payment. As a result, most PILON payments are fully subject to both income tax and NICs.


Why HMRC Generally Excludes PILON from Being Pensionable

HMRC’s exclusion of PILON from pensionable income is largely due to the nature of the payment. Since PILON replaces the employee's regular wages during the notice period, HMRC treats it as taxable earnings rather than a pensionable benefit. Here are some additional reasons why PILON is typically excluded from pensionable income:


  1. Distinction from Redundancy Payments: Unlike redundancy payments, which may include a pension component in certain cases, PILON is primarily a replacement for lost wages. This difference is crucial in tax treatment, as redundancy payments up to £30,000 can often be tax-free. PILON, however, does not qualify for this tax-free status in most cases.

  2. Alignment with Taxable Earnings: HMRC categorizes PILON under Section 62 of the Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003, which covers taxable employment income. This categorization means that PILON is inherently taxable and therefore not treated as a pensionable component. This approach streamlines the tax treatment of termination payments, creating consistency for both employers and employees.

  3. Pension Scheme Structures: Many pension schemes in the UK are structured based on regular earnings rather than termination payments. Defined contribution schemes, for instance, require ongoing contributions, which PILON does not facilitate. Consequently, the structure of these schemes does not accommodate one-off PILON payments, further limiting their pensionability.


Case-by-Case Considerations: Exceptions to the Rule

While PILON is not generally pensionable, exceptions do exist. Employers with bespoke or high-value contracts may negotiate specific terms that include pension contributions within PILON. Such cases are often seen in executive contracts or industries where retention and benefits are highly competitive. However, these instances are uncommon and typically apply to a minority of employees.


For example, a senior executive in a financial institution might negotiate a contract that includes pensionable PILON. In such cases, the employer’s pension scheme administrator would need to coordinate with HMRC to ensure compliance with both pension and tax laws. This process can be complex and costly, which is why many employers avoid making PILON pensionable unless there is a clear strategic benefit.


Practical Implications for Employers and Employees

For employers, correctly classifying and managing PILON payments is crucial. Misclassifying PILON as non-taxable or pensionable can result in significant tax liabilities and potential penalties from HMRC. Employers should clearly outline the terms of PILON in employment contracts, specifying whether pension contributions apply and ensuring that tax and NIC calculations are accurately processed.


For employees, understanding whether PILON includes pension contributions is essential for retirement planning. Employees receiving PILON should confirm with their HR or payroll departments if their PILON payment includes pension contributions. This information helps employees make informed decisions regarding their post-employment financial plans, including whether they may need to make voluntary pension contributions to offset any shortfall.


Tax Treatment of PILON and its Implications for UK Taxpayers

In the UK, Payment in Lieu of Notice (PILON) carries specific tax implications, particularly following HMRC's regulatory updates. Understanding the detailed tax treatment of PILON can help employees and employers manage financial planning and ensure compliance. While PILON is classified as a taxable component of termination payments, several nuances impact how income tax and National Insurance Contributions (NICs) apply.


Why PILON is Subject to Tax and NICs

Historically, PILON was considered non-taxable if it was not explicitly mentioned in an employment contract. However, HMRC revised these rules, clarifying that PILON is taxable regardless of its contractual status. This change aimed to close loopholes and create fairness, ensuring that all termination-related payments are consistently treated under the tax system.


Relevant Legislation:

The tax treatment of PILON falls under Section 62 of the Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003 (ITEPA 2003). Under this legislation, PILON is classified as “earnings” and therefore subject to income tax and NICs as standard employment income. This tax treatment differentiates PILON from certain redundancy payments, which can be tax-free up to £30,000.


Key Components of PILON Taxation

  1. Income Tax: PILON payments are subject to income tax at the employee’s normal rate. Depending on the individual’s total income for the year, this tax rate can be 20%, 40%, or 45%, aligned with the UK’s progressive tax system. For example, if a middle-income employee with an annual salary of £40,000 receives a PILON payment of £5,000, this payment will be taxed at 20%, assuming no other income adjustments.

  2. National Insurance Contributions (NICs): Similar to income tax, NICs are payable on PILON, treating the payment as ordinary earnings. Both employer and employee contributions are calculated and deducted. Employee NICs depend on their earnings category (e.g., Class 1 contributions), while employers must account for Class 1 secondary NICs on the payment. For employees, this deduction can range from 12% to 2%, depending on their income bracket, while employers typically contribute 13.8%.

  3. Interaction with Tax-Free Thresholds: The £30,000 tax-free threshold applies exclusively to certain termination payments. Since HMRC classifies PILON as a replacement for salary, it does not fall within the scope of this threshold. However, non-PILON elements of a termination package, such as redundancy pay, may qualify for tax-free status up to £30,000, provided they meet HMRC’s criteria. Employers should take care to separate PILON from other components when structuring termination payments to ensure accurate tax treatment.

  4. Post-Employment Notice Pay (PENP): Since April 2018, HMRC introduced a concept known as Post-Employment Notice Pay (PENP), which requires employers to calculate the taxable portion of termination payments based on unworked notice periods. This calculation applies to all terminations, aiming to capture tax on the earnings an employee would have received had they worked through their notice period. PILON, in most cases, will fall under PENP calculations, making it taxable under the same principles.


PILON and Tax Planning: Employer and Employee Considerations

Employers and employees both need to understand the tax impact of PILON for financial planning. For employers, accurate PILON classification is essential to avoid penalties, while employees should consider the tax implications on their severance packages to anticipate take-home pay accurately.


Employer Obligations: Employers must calculate income tax and NICs for PILON according to HMRC guidelines. Failure to do so can result in fines, back payments, and penalties. For payroll departments, it’s crucial to:

  • Correctly itemize PILON within severance payments.

  • Calculate PENP where applicable to determine the precise taxable amount.

  • Provide clear documentation to employees, specifying the tax treatment of each termination payment component.


Employee Tax Planning: For employees, understanding PILON’s taxability aids in financial planning. Since PILON is subject to both income tax and NICs, employees should anticipate potential deductions. Additionally, PILON is included in the calculation of total taxable income, which may push employees into a higher tax bracket. As a result, higher-income employees receiving PILON could face a 40% or 45% tax rate on their termination payments.


Example: Consider an employee earning £60,000 annually who receives a PILON of £10,000. With the employee already in the higher tax bracket, this £10,000 will be taxed at 40%, plus NIC deductions, potentially leaving them with less than 60% of the initial amount after taxes. Employees should consult tax advisors to explore any potential tax planning strategies, such as timing severance to avoid exceeding annual income thresholds where possible.


Updates and Amendments Impacting PILON Taxation

The 2024 UK Autumn Budget introduced some updates relevant to employment taxes, though there were no specific changes targeting PILON. However, broader income tax thresholds and NIC adjustments may indirectly influence the tax impact of PILON:


  1. Income Tax Bracket Adjustments: The budget confirmed a freeze on income tax thresholds, meaning more individuals may fall into higher tax brackets due to income growth. For employees receiving PILON in the current tax year, this means that larger PILON payments might push them into higher brackets, especially if they have a high base salary.

  2. NIC Thresholds: Similar to income tax, the NIC thresholds remain unchanged, which may indirectly increase NIC obligations for PILON payments. As NICs are calculated based on income levels, any rise in annual income due to PILON could lead to higher NIC deductions.

  3. Post-Budget Financial Planning: With thresholds frozen, employees and employers need to pay extra attention to the tax treatment of PILON to avoid unintended costs. Employees may want to work with advisors to determine how PILON could impact overall tax obligations, especially if termination payments coincide with bonus periods or other taxable income sources.


Practical Calculations: How PILON is Calculated and Taxed

Understanding the actual calculation of PILON can be complex, as it typically includes both salary and any contractual benefits an employee would have received during the notice period. Here’s a simplified calculation process:


  1. Base Salary for Notice Period: If an employee has a 3-month notice period and earns £4,000 monthly, the base PILON calculation would cover £12,000 in lost wages.

  2. Inclusion of Additional Benefits: Some contracts specify additional components within PILON, such as allowances or bonuses. For example, if the employee was due a monthly car allowance of £300, this would add an additional £900 over the notice period, bringing the total to £12,900.

  3. Tax and NIC Calculation: Based on a total PILON of £12,900:

    • Income Tax: If the employee is in the 20% tax bracket, income tax would amount to £2,580.

    • Employee NICs: Assuming 12% NICs, this would equate to £1,548.

    • Employer NICs: At a rate of 13.8%, employer NICs would total £1,780.20 (though this amount is paid by the employer, not deducted from the employee’s payout).

  4. Final Payment to Employee: After income tax and NIC deductions, the employee would receive approximately £8,772. Employers should provide breakdowns in termination letters to help employees understand these deductions.


Special Considerations for High Earners

High-income individuals face unique challenges with PILON due to the higher tax brackets. An employee in the 45% tax bracket receiving a large PILON can experience significant tax deductions. In some cases, high earners negotiate alternative exit packages or timing adjustments to avoid excessive tax impacts on their termination payments. While this is not always feasible, tax planning can mitigate the financial impact for those in higher brackets.


The Importance of Documentation and Transparency

To maintain compliance with HMRC regulations and ensure clarity, employers are advised to document all components of PILON within employee termination letters. The following components are recommended:


  1. Clear Identification of PILON: Specify the notice period being compensated, the breakdown of salary and benefits included, and how these totals were calculated.

  2. Separate Pension and Non-Pension Contributions: Employers should clarify if pension contributions are part of PILON or not. As most PILON payments are non-pensionable, it’s essential to avoid any assumptions about pension contributions.

  3. Tax Breakdown: Providing a breakdown of income tax and NICs helps employees understand their final payout and anticipate potential tax adjustments.

  4. Guidance for Employees: Many employers include tax guidance, advising employees to consult with financial advisors if they have questions about the tax impact. Given the complexities of PILON, such guidance can improve employee satisfaction and reduce post-termination disputes.



Strategic Use of PILON in Workforce Management and Comparisons with Garden Leave

For employers, Payment in Lieu of Notice (PILON) is more than just a financial transaction; it is a strategic tool that allows for immediate workforce adjustments while minimizing potential disruption. Understanding the options surrounding termination payments, including how PILON compares with other exit arrangements like garden leave and redundancy pay, can empower businesses to make better decisions that align with legal requirements and business objectives.


Why Employers Use PILON as a Strategic Workforce Tool

PILON allows an employer to terminate employment contracts without the need for employees to serve out their notice periods. This immediate separation can be beneficial in several scenarios, particularly where business continuity, confidentiality, or operational efficiency is a concern. Here’s how PILON can be strategically useful:


  1. Maintaining Confidentiality and Reducing Risk: For roles involving access to sensitive information, particularly in sectors like finance, tech, or law, immediate termination via PILON is often preferred to prevent the potential misuse of proprietary information during a notice period. By paying out the notice period instead, employers limit any risk to their business while compensating the employee fairly.

  2. Enhancing Morale and Reducing Workplace Tensions: Employees serving notice periods may experience low motivation or tension within the workplace, especially if they are leaving due to disputes or redundancy. Offering PILON provides a clean break, allowing both parties to part ways amicably and maintaining morale among the remaining team.

  3. Facilitating Rapid Organizational Change: In cases where rapid restructuring is needed, PILON offers a quick solution to free up roles or bring in replacements without the waiting period associated with traditional notice periods. For example, when companies undergo mergers, downsizing, or strategic shifts, PILON is often preferred as it accelerates the transition process.


PILON vs. Garden Leave: Key Differences and Considerations

In practice, PILON is often compared to garden leave as both are alternatives to having an employee work through their notice period. However, the two approaches are distinctly different in how they impact employment contracts, employee rights, and employer obligations.


1. Garden Leave Explained:

Garden leave is a scenario where an employee is still technically employed and on the payroll, but they do not attend the workplace or perform duties during their notice period. Garden leave serves several purposes:


  • Prevents Conflicts of Interest: By keeping employees on the payroll but away from active work, employers prevent them from joining competitors or accessing confidential information that could be detrimental to the business.

  • Restricts Job-Seeking: During garden leave, employees remain legally bound to their employer and may face restrictions on seeking new employment until the notice period concludes. This is beneficial to employers who want to control the timing of an employee’s exit to reduce competitive threats.

  • Allows Time for Succession Planning: Employers can use garden leave to prepare for a successor or train internal replacements while the departing employee remains on standby if consultation is needed.


2. Comparing Financial and Legal Implications:

Both PILON and garden leave involve costs, but their financial structures differ:

  • Payment Terms: PILON is typically a lump-sum payment, while garden leave involves regular salary payments for the notice period.

  • Pension Contributions and Benefits: On garden leave, employees often retain their standard benefits, including pension contributions. PILON, as we’ve discussed, rarely includes pension contributions unless explicitly stated in the contract.

  • Tax Implications: For the employer, NICs and tax calculations differ slightly between PILON and garden leave. Since garden leave payments are part of regular payroll, tax deductions occur in real time, while PILON is a one-time deduction.


3. Strategic Use Cases:

Employers might opt for PILON or garden leave depending on the specific scenario. For example:


  • PILON is ideal when the goal is an immediate, complete separation.

  • Garden Leave works best when an employer needs a phased exit or wants to prevent an employee from immediately joining a competitor.


PILON and Redundancy Pay: Distinguishing the Two

Another common source of confusion among employees and employers is the difference between PILON and redundancy pay. While both can be part of a termination package, their purposes and tax treatments differ significantly.


1. Purpose and Definition

  • PILON compensates an employee for their notice period when employment ends immediately.

  • Redundancy Pay is compensation for loss of employment due to organizational restructuring, downsizing, or role elimination. This payment recognizes the employee’s contributions and the inconvenience of job loss.


2. Tax Treatment

  • PILON is taxable as earnings, and no part of it qualifies for the £30,000 tax-free exemption typically available in redundancy payments.

  • Redundancy Pay up to £30,000 can often be tax-free, provided it meets HMRC’s criteria. Any redundancy payment exceeding this amount is subject to tax.


3. Pension Contributions

Generally, redundancy payments do not impact pension contributions unless specifically agreed. Similarly, PILON is not typically pensionable unless contractually specified, though redundancy packages occasionally include negotiated pension contributions, especially in cases of early retirement.


Example: Consider a scenario where an employee with a long tenure at a company is made redundant and given a £20,000 redundancy payment alongside a PILON of £5,000. The £20,000 redundancy payment would be tax-free under the £30,000 threshold, while the £5,000 PILON would be fully taxed, adding a financial planning consideration for the employee.


Managing PILON for Different Employee Classes

For companies, managing PILON varies depending on the employee’s position, role, and tenure within the organization. Senior executives, for instance, often have complex employment contracts with clauses regarding termination and benefits, while junior roles typically involve simpler, standard contracts. Here’s how PILON management can differ by role type:


  1. Senior Executives: Executives often have termination clauses that may include enhanced PILON terms. These clauses are designed to retain key talent but also to protect the company from potential conflicts of interest upon termination. PILON for executives can include benefits beyond salary, such as a portion of their bonus or deferred compensation, though this is less common.

  2. Standard Employees: For most employees, PILON usually involves a straightforward calculation based on base salary for the notice period. Employers may offer PILON selectively, especially if they need to mitigate redundancy costs or streamline a restructuring process.

  3. Short-Term and Contract Workers: PILON is less common for short-term or contract workers, as they are often employed under different terms with shorter notice periods. In cases where PILON applies, it generally includes only base pay without additional benefits.


Practical Challenges for Employers Using PILON

Implementing PILON can pose several challenges for employers, especially when managing a large-scale termination process, restructuring, or downsizing event. Here are some of the common challenges:


  1. Ensuring Tax Compliance: Employers must stay vigilant about compliance, particularly regarding income tax and NICs. Incorrect classification or calculation of PILON can lead to HMRC scrutiny, back payments, or fines. Given the complexity of PILON, it is crucial to involve payroll and legal experts during the process.

  2. Aligning with Employment Law: Employment contracts need to be carefully reviewed and updated to ensure clarity on PILON. If PILON terms are ambiguous or missing, employees might dispute the payment structure, leading to legal complications. Having clear, explicit terms in contracts regarding PILON treatment can help prevent disputes.

  3. Communication with Employees: When offering PILON, employers should communicate clearly with employees to avoid misunderstandings regarding tax treatment, pension contributions, and other deductions. Detailed termination letters or exit documentation are essential in explaining PILON breakdowns, ensuring that employees understand how their final pay has been calculated.

  4. Managing Employee Expectations: Employees may expect PILON to cover additional benefits, like pension contributions, or to be tax-free, which is rarely the case. Managing these expectations can help avoid dissatisfaction or disputes post-termination. Employers should clarify during exit discussions that PILON is generally a substitute for wages, not a benefit package extension.


Best Practices for Employers Implementing PILON

To maximize the effectiveness of PILON as a workforce management tool, employers should adhere to best practices that enhance clarity, compliance, and employee relations. Here are a few recommendations:


  1. Standardize PILON Policies: Developing standardized PILON policies helps ensure consistency across the organization. For larger firms, having a clear framework for when PILON applies and how it is calculated can simplify the process, reduce confusion, and ensure compliance.

  2. Consult Legal and Payroll Professionals: Given the tax and legal complexities associated with PILON, consulting with legal experts and payroll specialists can prevent costly mistakes. A professional review can also ensure that termination payments align with HMRC rules, avoiding penalties.

  3. Document Clearly: Providing a written breakdown of PILON calculations in the employee’s final pay statement enhances transparency. Employees should receive a detailed breakdown showing their gross PILON, tax deductions, NICs, and net payout.

  4. Tailor PILON Use to Business Objectives: PILON can be a flexible tool when tailored to organizational goals. In scenarios requiring immediate employee separation, PILON offers a quick, cost-effective solution. However, for sensitive exits where transitioning knowledge is essential, garden leave may be a more appropriate choice.

  5. Consider Alternative Compensation Strategies: For senior roles, consider including a deferred compensation arrangement or a “clawback” clause to retain top talent while managing risks. Deferred compensation may offer tax advantages for both employer and employee and is often more palatable than a one-off PILON payment.



Regulatory Obligations, HMRC Guidance, and Legal Implications of PILON

The use of Payment in Lieu of Notice (PILON) is not just a financial decision—it also has significant regulatory and legal implications. For employers, understanding HMRC guidelines and the relevant employment laws surrounding PILON is essential to avoid potential disputes, penalties, and compliance risks. In this section, we will delve into the regulatory aspects of PILON, including the tax rules established by HMRC, common legal issues that arise with PILON misclassification, and best practices to maintain compliance.


HMRC Guidance on PILON: Key Points and Compliance Requirements

The tax treatment of PILON by HMRC is designed to ensure consistency across different types of termination payments. Since PILON is effectively a replacement for income that an employee would have received if they had worked their notice period, HMRC treats it as part of the employee’s earnings. This classification has specific tax implications, impacting both the income tax and National Insurance Contributions (NICs) that apply.


1. Earnings Classification under HMRC Rules:

HMRC categorizes PILON as taxable earnings under Section 62 of the Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003 (ITEPA 2003). This means that PILON is not eligible for tax-free treatment, unlike certain redundancy payments. From HMRC’s perspective, PILON is essentially delayed salary, hence why it is fully taxable and subject to NICs as standard earnings would be.


2. The Impact of Post-Employment Notice Pay (PENP):

In 2018, HMRC introduced the concept of Post-Employment Notice Pay (PENP) to standardize the tax treatment of notice period payments. Under PENP, any portion of a termination payment that represents a notice period not worked is taxable as earnings, regardless of whether the contract specifies PILON. This rule effectively closed a previous loophole where non-contractual PILON could sometimes be classified as tax-free. Now, any unworked notice period is automatically subject to tax and NICs, ensuring that HMRC captures tax on all notice period payments.


3. Reporting and Compliance:

HMRC requires employers to report PILON in real-time through the PAYE (Pay As You Earn) system. Employers must calculate income tax and NICs at the time of payment, ensuring that deductions align with current tax rates. Real-time reporting helps HMRC monitor compliance, and failing to report PILON correctly can lead to audits or penalties. Employers should keep detailed records of PILON calculations, especially in cases where contracts specify unique terms for notice payments.


Common Legal Issues and Disputes with PILON

When PILON is misclassified or incorrectly calculated, it can lead to legal disputes. Employees may challenge the amount of their PILON or question its tax treatment, especially if they were unaware that their contract stipulated specific terms for notice payments. Here are some of the common legal issues employers face with PILON:


1. Misclassification of PILON:

One of the most common issues is the incorrect classification of PILON, particularly when an employer treats PILON as tax-free or fails to apply NICs. HMRC considers this a breach of tax regulations, and employers found misclassifying PILON could be liable for back taxes, NICs, and penalties.


2. Contractual Ambiguities:

Ambiguities in employment contracts regarding PILON terms can lead to disputes between employees and employers. For instance, if an employment contract does not explicitly mention PILON but the employer issues it at termination, the employee might question the tax deductions applied. Similarly, if the contract is unclear about whether PILON includes additional benefits or pension contributions, employees may contest the payment amount.


3. Discrimination and Fairness Claims:

In some cases, employees may claim that PILON terms are discriminatory, especially if PILON is offered selectively within the organization. For instance, if senior executives receive a PILON with additional benefits while other employees do not, this could lead to claims of unfair treatment. Employers should implement consistent PILON policies to minimize the risk of discrimination claims.


4. Misunderstandings around Garden Leave vs. PILON:

Confusion around garden leave and PILON often leads to disputes, particularly when an employee expects to be put on garden leave but receives a PILON instead. Garden leave allows employees to retain benefits, including pension contributions, during the notice period, whereas PILON typically does not. Ensuring that employees understand the type of exit arrangement they will receive can prevent potential disputes.


Penalties for Non-Compliance with HMRC PILON Rules

Non-compliance with HMRC’s PILON rules can result in substantial penalties for employers. Penalties vary based on the severity of non-compliance and whether HMRC views the issue as deliberate or an honest error. Here’s a breakdown of the penalties that can apply:


  1. Tax Penalties: If an employer fails to correctly classify PILON and treats it as tax-free, HMRC can impose penalties for underpaid tax. These penalties are typically calculated as a percentage of the unpaid tax amount, with rates depending on the reason for non-compliance. For example:

    • Careless Mistakes: Penalties can reach up to 30% of the unpaid tax if HMRC deems the error a result of carelessness.

    • Deliberate Misreporting: Penalties can reach 100% of the unpaid tax if HMRC finds that the employer deliberately misreported PILON to avoid taxes.

  2. NICs Penalties: Employers who fail to apply NICs to PILON payments face additional penalties. NIC penalties are typically aligned with tax penalties, with similar percentages applied based on the nature of the error. Since NICs are a statutory obligation, HMRC closely monitors NIC compliance for PILON.

  3. Interest on Unpaid Taxes and NICs: In addition to penalties, HMRC may charge interest on unpaid taxes and NICs. This interest compounds over time, making it essential for employers to rectify any PILON misclassification as soon as it is identified to avoid escalating costs.

  4. Audit and Investigation Risks: Employers who fail to report PILON correctly may trigger HMRC audits, leading to increased scrutiny of payroll records and employment contracts. An audit can be time-consuming and costly, especially if it uncovers additional non-compliance issues. To avoid audits, employers should conduct regular reviews of their PILON processes, ensuring they align with HMRC’s latest guidance.


Employment Law Considerations Surrounding PILON

Beyond HMRC’s tax requirements, PILON is subject to broader employment laws that govern termination payments, notice periods, and contractual rights. Employers should be aware of these legal considerations to avoid potential claims from employees.


1. Statutory Notice Periods:

UK employment law mandates statutory notice periods based on the employee’s length of service. For example, employees with one to two years of service are entitled to one week of notice, while those with over twelve years are entitled to twelve weeks. Employers must ensure that any PILON payment meets these statutory requirements, even if the employment contract specifies a shorter notice period.


2. Right to Notice Pay:

Employees have a statutory right to notice pay, and PILON can fulfill this requirement. However, PILON should match the amount the employee would have received if they had worked their notice period. Underpaying PILON can lead to claims for unpaid wages, and employees might argue that their rights were violated if the payment falls short of their statutory entitlements.


3. Unfair Dismissal and Wrongful Termination Claims:

Incorrect handling of PILON can lead to claims of unfair dismissal or wrongful termination. For instance, if an employer provides insufficient notice or fails to make a proper PILON payment, employees may seek legal recourse, particularly if they feel that their termination was handled improperly. PILON can mitigate such claims by fulfilling notice pay obligations, but only if the payment aligns with contractual and statutory requirements.


4. Inclusion of Benefits in PILON:

While HMRC generally does not consider PILON to be pensionable, employment contracts sometimes specify that benefits, such as health insurance or car allowances, should continue during the notice period. Employers should carefully review employment contracts to determine whether these benefits must be included in the PILON calculation. Failure to include contractual benefits can lead to breach of contract claims from employees.


Mitigating Legal Risks: Best Practices for Employers

To minimize the risk of legal issues and ensure compliance with HMRC regulations, employers should adopt best practices when offering PILON. Here are some key recommendations:


  1. Review Employment Contracts Regularly: Employers should conduct periodic reviews of employment contracts, ensuring that PILON terms are clear, up-to-date, and aligned with HMRC’s tax guidance. Standardizing PILON clauses across the organization can help prevent ambiguity and promote fair treatment.

  2. Provide Detailed Documentation: When offering PILON, employers should issue a termination letter or exit package breakdown that details how PILON was calculated, including any deductions for tax and NICs. Documentation should also clarify that PILON does not include benefits unless specified in the contract. Providing detailed information helps employees understand their final pay and reduces the likelihood of disputes.

  3. Separate PILON from Other Termination Payments: To avoid confusion and ensure accurate tax treatment, employers should clearly separate PILON from other termination payments, such as redundancy pay or ex gratia payments. This distinction allows each payment to be taxed appropriately and reduces the risk of misclassification.

  4. Train Payroll and HR Teams: Payroll and HR staff play a crucial role in implementing PILON correctly. Providing training on HMRC guidelines and the legal requirements surrounding PILON can help these teams manage the process accurately. Training ensures that employees receive accurate information about PILON and that deductions are handled correctly.



Practical Guidance for Employers and Employees on Managing PILON


Practical Guidance for Employers and Employees on Managing PILON

For employers and employees alike, handling Payment in Lieu of Notice (PILON) requires an understanding of both the practical and financial implications. From accurately calculating payments to managing expectations around tax deductions, clarity is essential to ensure compliance and maintain positive relationships during employment termination. In this final section, we provide practical advice for employers on how to administer PILON effectively, as well as guidance for employees to help them navigate the financial aspects of receiving PILON.


Employer Guidance: Best Practices for Administering PILON

Administering PILON efficiently requires a structured approach to ensure both legal compliance and fair treatment of employees. Below are some essential practices for employers managing PILON in termination situations:


1. Conduct Clear Communication with Employees

Transparency is key when informing employees about their PILON. Employers should explain the terms and calculations behind PILON payments, including any tax and NIC deductions, and clarify that these payments typically do not include pension contributions. By proactively addressing these details, employers reduce the risk of misunderstandings or disputes regarding the final payout.


  • Example: If an employee’s PILON amounts to £10,000 and falls within a 20% tax bracket, employers should explain that £2,000 will be deducted as income tax, plus NICs, to give the employee an understanding of their net amount.


2. Review and Standardize Employment Contracts

Consistent and clear PILON terms across employment contracts simplify the process of administering these payments. Employers should ensure that PILON clauses are uniformly defined, detailing what is included (e.g., basic salary or benefits) and whether pension contributions apply. This consistency not only aids compliance but also enhances transparency, as employees know what to expect.


3. Separate PILON from Other Termination Payments

Mixing PILON with other termination payments, such as redundancy pay, can lead to complications, especially when it comes to tax treatment. Employers should list each payment component separately on termination letters and payroll reports. By distinguishing PILON from other payments, employers can ensure accurate tax calculations and prevent confusion.


  • Example: An employee receiving a £15,000 redundancy payment and £5,000 in PILON would see each amount itemized separately, with redundancy pay potentially eligible for tax-free treatment under the £30,000 exemption, while PILON remains taxable.


4. Verify Compliance with HMRC’s Real-Time Reporting Requirements

Under HMRC’s real-time reporting rules, employers are required to report PILON payments promptly, ensuring that income tax and NIC deductions are applied correctly. Employers should verify that payroll systems are up-to-date and capable of handling PILON reporting accurately. Conducting regular payroll audits can further ensure compliance and reduce the risk of penalties.


5. Consult Legal and Tax Advisors for Complex Cases

In cases involving senior executives or bespoke contracts, PILON terms may be more complex, including additional benefits or specific tax considerations. Consulting with legal and tax experts can help ensure that these cases are handled accurately. Advisors can assist with interpreting contract terms, advising on tax efficiency, and ensuring that all PILON-related obligations are met.


Employee Guidance: Managing the Financial Impact of PILON

For employees, understanding the financial implications of PILON is crucial for effective financial planning, especially given the tax liabilities associated with these payments. Below is a practical guide for employees receiving PILON to help them navigate their final payout.


1. Clarify the Terms of PILON in Your Contract

Before leaving an employer, employees should review their contract to understand how PILON is calculated and what is included. Contracts should specify whether PILON covers only base salary or additional benefits and whether it impacts pension contributions. This review provides employees with clarity on their entitlements, helping them anticipate the amount they will receive.


  • Example: If an employee’s contract states that PILON includes only base salary, they should not expect benefits like health insurance or car allowances to be part of the payment.


2. Account for Tax and NIC Deductions

Since PILON is fully subject to income tax and NICs, employees should be prepared for deductions. Consulting with an HR representative or payroll advisor can help employees understand these deductions, allowing them to manage their expectations around take-home pay.


  • Example: An employee in the 40% tax bracket with a PILON of £8,000 should expect £3,200 in tax deductions, resulting in a net payout of approximately £4,800 after accounting for NICs as well.


3. Understand the Timing of PILON Payments

The timing of PILON payments can impact an employee’s total income for the year, potentially affecting their tax bracket. Employees with high annual incomes may find that receiving PILON pushes them into a higher tax bracket, resulting in a larger tax liability. In such cases, employees may want to seek advice on timing or tax planning strategies to manage the financial impact effectively.


4. Confirm Whether Pension Contributions are Included

Generally, PILON does not include pension contributions unless specifically stated in the contract. Employees concerned about a gap in their pension contributions due to PILON may consider making voluntary contributions or discussing options with a financial advisor to avoid any long-term impact on their retirement savings.


5. Seek Financial Planning Advice if Necessary

For individuals receiving substantial PILON payments, especially those in higher tax brackets, consulting a financial advisor can help manage the tax burden and optimize financial outcomes. Advisors can provide guidance on investment options, tax planning, and pension contributions to help employees maintain financial stability post-employment.


PILON in Special Circumstances: Insights for Both Employers and Employees

Certain special circumstances can affect the administration and impact of PILON, including redundancy scenarios, senior executive exits, and voluntary departures. Here are insights into how PILON might differ in these cases:


1. Redundancy Situations

While redundancy pay can be tax-free up to £30,000, PILON is not eligible for this exemption as it represents payment for notice periods rather than compensation for job loss. Employers structuring redundancy packages should ensure that PILON is clearly separated from redundancy pay to avoid confusion about tax treatment.


  • Example: An employee made redundant may receive a £20,000 redundancy payment tax-free, but if they also receive a £5,000 PILON, it will be fully taxable, affecting their total net payout.


2. Executive Terminations and Bespoke Contracts

Senior executives and high-ranking employees often have customized termination terms, including PILON clauses that may encompass additional benefits or deferred compensation. In such cases, employers must ensure that these payments comply with HMRC guidelines, and employees should seek financial advice on managing the impact on their tax liability.


3. Voluntary Departures and PILON

In voluntary resignations, PILON is generally not applied unless explicitly agreed upon by both parties. Employers may offer PILON in certain cases to facilitate a swift departure or to avoid potential conflicts of interest. Employees leaving voluntarily should confirm the terms with their employer to avoid any surprises regarding final pay and benefits.


Avoiding Common Mistakes with PILON Administration

Both employers and employees should be mindful of common mistakes that can arise during the PILON process. Here are a few potential pitfalls and ways to avoid them:


  • Incorrect Tax Treatment: Employers should avoid assuming that PILON is tax-free. HMRC requires PILON to be fully taxable, and incorrect classification can lead to costly penalties. Employers should verify with their payroll department to ensure accurate tax treatment.

  • Ambiguity in Employment Contracts: Employers should clearly outline PILON terms within employment contracts, specifying whether PILON includes additional benefits or pension contributions. Contracts lacking clear language can lead to disputes and legal complications.

  • Overlooking NIC Obligations: Since PILON is treated as regular earnings, both employers and employees are liable for NICs. Employers should calculate NICs accurately, including Class 1 NICs for both employee and employer contributions.

  • Miscommunication with Employees: Clear communication with employees regarding PILON terms, tax implications, and benefits exclusions is essential. Employers should provide employees with a detailed breakdown of their PILON to ensure full transparency.


Summary of Key Points for Employers and Employees

To conclude this section, here’s a recap of the essential points for both parties involved in PILON:


For Employers:

  • Review employment contracts to ensure clarity on PILON terms.

  • Maintain consistent policies on PILON application, particularly across different employee levels.

  • Accurately report and classify PILON in compliance with HMRC regulations, ensuring tax and NIC obligations are met.

  • Communicate transparently with employees about the components of PILON and any associated tax deductions.

For Employees:

  • Review your employment contract for clarity on PILON and what is included.

  • Account for tax and NIC deductions when budgeting for your final payout.

  • Confirm if any pension contributions or benefits are included in PILON.

  • Seek professional advice if you are unsure about the financial implications of receiving PILON.


With these practical insights, both employers and employees can better understand and navigate the complexities surrounding PILON. For employers, correct administration of PILON can enhance compliance and mitigate legal risks, while employees can manage their financial expectations effectively. Whether in large organizations or small businesses, PILON remains a vital tool for managing workforce transitions in a way that balances regulatory requirements with fair treatment for employees.



FAQs


Q1: Is PILON mandatory for all employers in the UK?

A: No, PILON is not mandatory. It depends on the employment contract terms or if the employer chooses to offer it.


Q2: Can PILON affect your eligibility for state benefits in the UK?

A: Yes, receiving PILON may impact means-tested benefits, as it counts as income and can affect benefit entitlements.


Q3: Are there differences in PILON rules between England, Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland?

A: Generally, PILON rules are consistent across the UK, but some local laws or practices may slightly affect employment terms.


Q4: Can you negotiate PILON terms in your employment contract?

A: Yes, in some cases, employees can negotiate PILON terms, especially if they have unique benefits or high-level roles.


Q5: Does PILON affect your tax-free personal allowance?

A: Yes, PILON counts as income, which can push your earnings into a higher bracket, reducing your personal allowance if above £100,000.


Q6: Is PILON subject to any capital gains tax in the UK?

A: No, PILON is not subject to capital gains tax; it is considered earnings and subject only to income tax and NICs.


Q7: Can PILON impact your entitlement to maternity or paternity pay?

A: PILON can impact statutory maternity or paternity pay if it raises your earnings or affects your entitlement calculations.


Q8: Is there any difference between PILON and severance pay?

A: Yes, PILON compensates for unworked notice periods, while severance pay is a broader term for end-of-employment payments.


Q9: Can PILON affect your eligibility for the Marriage Allowance in the UK?

A: Yes, PILON is treated as income, and it can impact eligibility for the Marriage Allowance if it increases taxable income limits.


Q10: How does PILON differ from statutory redundancy payments?

A: PILON replaces notice pay and is taxable, while statutory redundancy pay is a separate payment and may be tax-free up to £30,000.


Q11: Can PILON payments be made tax-free if the employer and employee agree?

A: No, HMRC rules state that PILON must be taxed as income, regardless of mutual agreements.


Q12: Is it possible to include a bonus in PILON?

A: It depends on the contract; some employers may include a prorated bonus in PILON if outlined in employment terms.


Q13: Can you request PILON if it is not included in your contract?

A: You may request it, but it is at the employer’s discretion unless the contract specifies PILON as an entitlement.


Q14: Does receiving PILON affect your pension contributions if you are in a defined benefit scheme?

A: It may; in most cases, PILON does not contribute to defined benefit pensions, but it’s best to check with the pension scheme.


Q15: Does PILON impact eligibility for working tax credits?

A: Yes, since PILON is counted as income, it may impact eligibility and the amount of working tax credits received.


Q16: Is PILON treated differently for employees on fixed-term contracts?

A: No, PILON is treated the same for all employment types, though contract terms may vary by employer.


Q17: Can PILON be included in settlement agreements?

A: Yes, PILON is often included in settlement agreements, where tax and NIC treatment should still align with HMRC rules.


Q18: Is PILON applicable if an employee is terminated for gross misconduct?

A: Generally, PILON is not provided for terminations due to gross misconduct, unless specified otherwise in the employment contract.


Q19: Can you defer a PILON payment to a later tax year to reduce tax liability?

A: Employers must report PILON in real time, so deferring it is typically not an option under HMRC rules.


Q20: Can employers deduct money from PILON if the employee owes the company?

A: Yes, employers may deduct amounts owed by the employee from the PILON, depending on the contract and agreements.


Q21: Does PILON affect eligibility for Universal Credit?

A: Yes, PILON can impact Universal Credit, as it is considered income and may reduce the amount of credit received.


Q22: Is PILON treated as part of earnings for mortgage applications?

A: PILON is often treated as regular earnings by mortgage lenders, so it may impact income assessments for applications.


Q23: Can PILON affect student loan repayments?

A: Yes, PILON is counted as income, so it may increase the amount deducted for student loan repayments if it raises earnings.


Q24: Is PILON applicable for employees on zero-hours contracts?

A: PILON terms vary for zero-hours contracts, and it’s up to employer discretion if notice pay is included for these employees.


Q25: Can you receive PILON while on long-term sick leave?

A: If the contract includes PILON, it may apply, though sick pay rules and contract terms can affect the final payment.


Q26: How is PILON calculated for part-time employees?

A: PILON for part-time employees is calculated based on their contracted hours and pro-rata earnings for the notice period.


Q27: Can PILON be paid in installments?

A: Typically, PILON is paid as a lump sum, but in some cases, employers and employees may agree on installments.


Q28: Is PILON taken into account for annual tax returns?

A: Yes, as part of employment earnings, PILON should be included in your tax return if required by your income level.


Q29: Can you get PILON if you are on a probationary period?

A: It depends on the employer's policy and the employment contract; some contracts exclude PILON during probation.


Q30: Are there special rules for PILON in the financial services industry?

A: While general PILON rules apply, some financial firms may have additional regulations for PILON due to industry standards.


Q31: Does PILON affect child benefit payments?

A: Yes, PILON increases your income, which may affect child benefit entitlements if your income exceeds certain thresholds.


Q32: Can PILON payments be reclaimed if there was an overpayment?

A: Employers may reclaim overpaid PILON if there was a mistake, provided the employee was informed of the correct amount.


Q33: Are PILON payments subject to the Apprenticeship Levy for employers?

A: Yes, PILON is subject to the Apprenticeship Levy, as it is classified as earnings in payroll calculations.


Q34: Can you refuse PILON if you prefer to work your notice period?

A: In most cases, PILON is the employer’s decision, and employees generally cannot refuse it if offered by the employer.


Q35: Can PILON impact eligibility for future employment benefits with the same employer?A: PILON itself may not, but how the exit is handled could affect rehire eligibility, depending on employer policies.


Q36: Is PILON taxable if you relocate abroad immediately after termination?

A: Yes, PILON is taxable as UK earnings, even if you relocate, as it pertains to employment within the UK.


Q37: Can PILON payments be subject to clawback provisions in executive contracts?

A: Yes, some executive contracts include clawback clauses, which may apply to PILON if stipulated in contract terms.


Q38: Does PILON impact auto-enrolment for workplace pensions?

A: Generally, PILON does not impact auto-enrolment as it is a termination payment, not regular earnings eligible for contributions.


Q39: Can you receive PILON after giving voluntary notice of resignation?

A: Employers are not obligated to offer PILON for voluntary resignations unless specified in the employment contract.


Q40: Is PILON eligible for charitable payroll giving deductions?

A: No, PILON is not eligible for charitable payroll giving deductions, as it is a one-time termination payment, not regular income.


Disclaimer:

The information provided in our articles is for general informational purposes only and is not intended as professional advice. While we strive to keep the information up-to-date and correct, My Tax Accountant makes no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, about the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability with respect to the website or the information, products, services, or related graphics contained in the articles for any purpose. Any reliance you place on such information is therefore strictly at your own risk.


We encourage all readers to consult with a qualified professional before making any decisions based on the information provided. The tax and accounting rules in the UK are subject to change and can vary depending on individual circumstances. Therefore, My Tax Accountant cannot be held liable for any errors, omissions, or inaccuracies published. The firm is not responsible for any losses, injuries, or damages arising from the display or use of this information.

112 views0 comments

Related Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page